top of page

Welcome to Crime and Justice News

Minnesotans Seeking Pardons Have 10 Minutes To Make Their Cases

Minnesota residents seeking pardons have only ten minutes to make their cases to a three member board consisting of the governor, attorney general and state's chief justice. Among recent applicants: a man caught a quarter-century ago with 127 doses of LSD, a pony-tailed Navy veteran who critically injured someone while driving drunk in 2008, a man twice convicted of assaulting his wife, now sitting beside him, and a former addict once found unconscious in a car, syringe jutting from his arm. They came to the Minnesota capital of St. Paul to be forgiven. The three members of the Board of Pardons sat, unsmiling, at a long table facing a much smaller table that featured tissue boxes and a digital clock set at 10 minutes, the New York Times reports.

It is a raw pardon process unlike those in most other states, with the powerless beseeching the powerful in public, and the decision rendered in the moment. When Gov. Tim Walz, 59, a retired high school teacher and former congressman, took office in 2019, his knowledge of his pardon power came mostly from movies. “Theoretically, I understood,” he said. “Operationally, no idea.” Now, with eight rounds of pardon hearings behind him, the governor understood the realities. To his left sat Chief Justice Lorie Gildea, a conservative Republican. To his right, Attorney General Keith Ellison, like him a progressive Democrat. “I remind folks in here that this is not a court of law,” the governor said. “This is a Board of Pardons to take in those very human experiences.” “Mercy is a requirement for justice, given how punishment actually operates in the world,” said New York University law Prof. Rachel Barkow. “For us to assume there’s a concept of perfect justice, it means we would know how a person will evolve and change over time.” There are other systems for restoring legal and social status, including diversion programs, expungement and record-sealing. Pardons carry the emotional heft of society’s forgiveness. Depending on the jurisdiction, their application can be transparent or mysterious, reasoned or arbitrary, even questionable, with some reformers calling them a capricious relic


Recent Posts

See All

A New York judge vacated two wrongful convictions Monday after reinvestigations found the murder trials were based on incorrect testimony, the district attorney in Manhattan announced, USA Today repor

A daily report co-sponsored by Arizona State University, Criminal Justice Journalists, and the National Criminal Justice Association

bottom of page